A commonplace book

control

60 quotes, with its narrower concepts

Alsomanipulation
narrowerbehaviorbureaucracyhierarchyneo-Taylorismovermanagementpanopticismrules
relatedaccountabilityconfinementconflictdominationhubrismanagementpower

Quotes

  1. In my view the computer is the Trojan Horse with which Taylorism is going to be introduced into intellectual work. When a human being interacts with a machine, the interaction is between two dialectical opposites. The human is slow, inconsistent, unreliable but highly creative, whereas the machine is a fast, reliable but totally non-creative.

    Morgan, Gareth, Creative Organization Theory (1989), p. 62

    neo-Taylorism

  2. Workers whose work rules were not rigidly defined but were instead allowed to make their own decisions about the production process turned out to be both more productive and better satisfied with their jobs. Workers under these conditions showed considerable interest in helping one another and created their own system of leaders and mutual support if left to themselves.

    Trust: The Social Virtues and the Creation of Prosperity (1995), p. 230

    autonomyrules

  3. There are two images then, of discipline. At one extreme, the discipline-blockade, the enclosed institution, established on the edges of society, turned inwards towards negative functions: arresting evil, breaking communications, suspending time. At the other extreme, with panopticism, is the discipline-mechanism: a functional mechanism that must improve the exercise of power by making it lighter, more rapid, more effective, a design of subtle coercion for a society to come. The movement from one project to the other, from a schema of exceptional discipline to one of a generalized surveillance, rests on a historical transformation: the gradual extension of the mechanisms of discipline throughout the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries, their spread throughout the whole social body, the formation of what might be called in general the disciplinary society.

    Foucault, M., Discipline and punish: The birth of the prison (1977), p. 209

    panopticism

  4. The danger of inappropriate intervention is especially likely if members mistakenly assume that people, rather than relationships, are the critical control points in an organization. The thrust of the organizing model is that it's easy to overmanage an organization and that is an excess rather than a deficiency of intervention that lies at the heart of many organizational problems.

    Weick, Karl, The Social Psychology of Organizing (1979), p. 244

    interventionovermanagement

  5. Power can mean power over people, or it can mean power to do things...Many writers, unfortunately, make use of this ambiguous meaning of the words 'power' and 'control', and in order to smuggle in the praise of 'power over' they identify it with 'power to'. Moreover, lack of control does not mean lack of any kind of organization, but only of those kinds in which the control is exploitative and the controlled cannot control the controllers.

    Fromm, Erich, The anatomy of human destructiveness (1973), p. 394

    controlpower

  6. As in any organization, rules were selectively evoked, broken, or ignored to suit the defined needs of personnel. Higher administrative levels, especially, avoided periodic attempts to have the rules codified and formalized, for fear of restricting the innovation and improvisation believed necessary to the care of patients. Also, the multiplicity of professional ideologies, theories, and purposes would never tolerate such a rigidification.

    Buckley, Walter, Sociology and modern systems theory. (1967), p. 150

    rules

  7. Any job that can be reduced to a set of rules is at risk. If a $500-a-month accountant in India doesn't swipe your accounting job, TurboTax will. Now that computers can emulate left-hemisphere skills, we'll have to rely ever more on our right hemispheres.

    Revenge of the Right Brain (2005)

    rules

  8. Recent international statistics on stress, burnout and healthy work organizations have indicated that many modern work organizations are consuming, rather than regenerating, their human resources. The brave new world of work envisaged to emerge from the ashes of Taylorism has not, in many cases, arrived and, where it has arrived, it has not been what it was expected to be. We have witnessed the persistence of Tayloristic organizations (Schumann et al. 1995) and the emergence of neo-Tayloristic organizations (Babson 1995; Landsbergis et al. 1999; Taylor and Bain 1999). At the same time, the post-bureaucratic organizations have not automatically created possibilities for mature adults to grow and develop (Argyris 1964); and where bureaucratic structures and rules have disappeared, they have rather left the mature adult lost, lonely and increasingly stressed.

    Docherty, Peter, Creating Sustainable Work Systems (2002), p. 3

    neo-Taylorism

  9. The sunflower effect--doing what your boss wants you to do--is still very powerful in all organizations because the power in all organizations is significantly at the top. Conflicts at high levels in organizations reverberate all the way down, reflecting the displacement downward of that anger and hostility and once again reflecting power at the top.

    Dixon, George, What works at work: lessons from the masters: personal profiles of 27 workplace experts and the 10 most important lessons they've learned about people, performance, and productivity (1988), p. 282

    hierarchy

  10. Bentham's panoptical vision served as an icon for a type of punishment society accepted as essential for its well-being. Panoptical power, however, is only one form of power, and the weakness in Foucault's argument is that it overlooks political concepts of power which depend in large measure on leaders' ideological and public pronouncements and on the willingness of followers to embrace the messages, intents, and weaknesses of their leaders.

    Glass, James, Psychosis and Power: Threats to democracy in the self and the group (1995), p. 112

    panopticism

  11. Finally, the traditional hierarchy--the pyramid structure of almost all organizations--has to be discarded. The traditional top-down method of leadership is wasteful and ineffective because a company's need to innovate continues to conflict with shared assumptions about loyalty and unquestioning obedience. This situation must change.

    Lauer, Chris, The Management Gurus: lessons from the best management books of all time (2008), p. 269

    hierarchy

  12. Good organizations are living bodies that grow new muscles to meet challenges. A chart demoralizes people. Nobody thinks of himself as below other people. And in a good company he isn't.

    Townsend, Robert, Further up the organization (1984), p. 159

    hierarchy

  13. This idea of productivity started in the 1980s, with the lionizing of the hardworking greedy. There's a critique of late capitalism to be had for sure, but what really devastated my generation was the spiritual malaise inherent in Taylorism's perfectly mechanized human labor. But Taylor had never seen a robot or a computer perfect his methods of being human. By the 1980s, we had. In the age of robots we reinvented the idea of being robots ourselves. We wanted to program our minds and bodies and have them obey clocks and routines. In this age of the human robot, of the materialist mind, being efficient took the pre-eminent spot, beyond goodness or power or wisdom or even cruel greed.

    Norton, Quinn, Against Productivity (2014)

    neo-Taylorismproductivity

  14. Corporations have used all of the control mechanisms at hand, techniques that have become both more sophisticated and punishing, to get fewer workers to convert ever more of their labor power into actual effort. This is true not just for manufacturing concerns like auto companies, which pioneered modern Taylorism, but by all private businesses (and public sector establishments such as colleges and the Social Security Administration), including especially today those in the service sector.

    Yates, Michael, The Growing Degradation of Work and Life, and What We Might Do to End It (2015)

    neo-Taylorism

  15. Feudal baronies prospered and grew in the European countryside in the eleventh-thirteenth centuries. And the equivalent of feudal baronies prospered and grew in U.S. corporations in the postwar period. Reflecting on this baronial culture in the early 1980's, an officer of Chemical Bank concluded: 'The way you got ahead was getting more people under you than your rival had, which created more bureaucracy, of course.' This dynamic creates a pressure for managerial ranks to expand even to greater size than might otherwise be justified by the criteria of profitability.

    Gordon, David, Fat and Mean: The Corporate Squeeze of Working Americans and the Myth of Managerial "Downsizing" (1996), p. 77

    bureaucracy

  16. Being powerless and hence in danger of being enslaved, or having power and hence in danger of becoming dehumanized, are two evils. Which is to be shunned the most is a matter of religious and moral or political conviction.

    Fromm, Erich, The anatomy of human destructiveness (1973), p. 395

    controlpower

  17. Surveillance contributes to discipline the surveilled (Haidt 2012). With surveillance and the information that results from it comes a disciplinary form of power (Foucault 1979). Monitoring and registering combined with rewards and sanctions for wanted and unwanted behavior is an efficient tool of behavior modification. Whether the surveillance takes place in institutions as prisons, schools, hospitals, the workplace, or the army or is generalized to the whole society, it aims at the same result: the production of obedient subjects who conform to what is expected and wanted by the authorities—normalized and law- and norm-abiding citizens.

    Vincent F. Hendricks; Mads Vestergaard, Reality Lost (2018), chap. 7.2

    conformitycontrolpanopticism

  18. The more strictly we are watched, the better we behave.

    Vincent F. Hendricks; Mads Vestergaard, Reality Lost (2018), chap. 7.2

    panopticism

  19. The solution is to change the user’s preferences so that they become more predictable. A more predictable user can be fed items that they are likely to click on, thereby generating more revenue.

    Stuart Russell, Human Compatible (2019), chap. 1

    controltechnology

  20. Like any rational entity, the algorithm learns how to modify the state of its environment—in this case, the user’s mind—in order to maximize its own reward.

    Stuart Russell, Human Compatible (2019), chap. 1

    controltechnology

← Previous41–60 of 60 quotes
Works quoted (51)