A commonplace book

control

60 quotes, with its narrower concepts

Alsomanipulation
narrowerbehaviorbureaucracyhierarchyneo-Taylorismovermanagementpanopticismrules
relatedaccountabilityconfinementconflictdominationhubrismanagementpower

Quotes

  1. Information technology operates through a series of displacements, from action to representation, from the politics of conflict to the invisible politics of forms and bureaucracy. Decades ago, Max Weber wrote of the iron cage of bureaucracy. Modern humans, he posited, are constrained at every juncture from true freedom of action by a set of rules of our own making. Some of these rules are formal, most are not. Information infrastructure adds another level of depth to the iron cage. In its layers, and in its complex interdependencies, it is a gossamer web with iron at its core.

    Bowker, Geoffrey C.; Star, Susan Leigh, Sorting things out: Classification and its consequences (1999), p. 320

    rulestechnology

  2. Much of what we call 'project management' stands upon Taylor's flat-earth perspectives. When applied to repeatable manufacturing situations, his primitive notions have great utility. The same ideas fall apart when applied in more human, less mechanical contexts.

    Schmaltz, David, The Blind Men and the Elephant: Mastering Project Work (2003), p. 7

    neo-Taylorism

  3. People stay with roles that frustrate them because of the dynamics of the structure. Something about their own lives, relationships, or position makes each person 'right' for the part he plays. It all seems so predetermined, yet the factors that create this may, individually, be quite inconsequential. People may even be drawn into the roles which clash with their personalities. Then, horrifyingly, their personalities may change over time to match the role they have been given.

    Senge, Peter; Kleiner, Art; Roberts, Charlotte et al., The Fifth Discipline Fieldbook (1994), p. 412

    role

  4. Corporations, for their part, have been engaged in a willful battle against the very grain of existence. Like the good Dutch boy with his finger in the dike, they have spent enormous amounts of energy putting in place systems that attempt to hold back the shifting, oceanic qualities of existence. The complexity of the world could be accounted for, they fervently hoped, by a simple increase in the thickness of the company manual.

    Whyte, David, The Heart Aroused: Poetry and the Preservation of the Soul in Corporate America (1996), p. 10

    rules

  5. In the past twenty-five years, computer-mediated work, despite its potential for reintegrating design and execution, has been employed, typically but not exclusively, in a manner that reproduces the hierarchies of managerial authority. The division between intellectual and manual labor and the degradation of manual labor that was characteristic of the industrializing era have been simultaneously shifted to the division between the operators and the professional-managerial employees, but also the division between the "lower" operating and "higher" expert orders broadly reproduces within intellectual labor itself the old gulf separating manual and intellectual labor in the mechanical era. Hierarchy is frequently maintained despite the integrative possibilities of the technology. Under this regime of production, the computer provides the basis for greatly extending the system of discipline and control inherited from nineteenth-century capitalism. Many corporations have used it to extend their Panopticonic world-view; that is, they have deployed the computer as a means of employee surveillance that far exceeds the most imperious dreams of the Panopticon's inventor, Jeremy Bentham, or any nineteenth- or early twentieth-century capitalist.

    Aronowitz, Stanley; Difazio, William, The Jobless Future: Sci-Tech and the Dogma of Work (1994), p. 89

    hierarchypanopticism

  6. In traditional hierarchical arrangements, those at the top of the pecking order can afford to be casual about how well they understand those at lower levels. But when people are more equal, they are obliged to make a greater effort to understand each other. If no one is the undisputed boss anymore, and if all insist on having their views respected, it follows that people must understand each other.

    Yankelovich, Daniel, The Magic of Dialogue: Transforming Conflict into Cooperation (1999), p. 18

    hierarchy

  7. One company we had the good fortune to work with some twenty years ago was shockingly changed when we visited it recently. People who had once cared deeply for one another and demonstrated high levels of creativity and innovation had become bureaucratized and uncaring, both in their work and in their interrelationships. The company had grown in size, but had shrunk in quality. Its earlier dynamism had become only a memory in the minds of the few who had originally created it.

    Allen, Robert; Kraft, Charlotte; Allen, Judd et al., The Organizational Unconscious: How to Create the Corporate Culture You Want and Need (1982), p. 110

    bureaucracy

  8. The knowledge obtained from accurate time study, for example, is a powerful implement, and can be used, in one case to promote harmony between workmen and the management, by gradually educating, training, and leading the workmen into new and better methods of doing work, or, in the other case, it may be used more or less as a club to drive the workmen into doing a larger day's work for approximately the same pay that they had received in the past.

    Taylor, F.W., The principles of scientific management (1911), p. 134

    neo-Taylorism

  9. The orthodox wisdom tells us that if we want major and rapid changes in behavior, then the only way to achieve them is for people to feel that their jobs are on the line. So, we are supposed to engineer circumstances that will create a sense of urgency--let us be honest, a sense of fear--within the body of our organizations. And with that stick we can beat our employees into a new mindset. The established dogma is a lie. Worse, it is a self serving and dangerous lie. It has become a myth that we have all been told for so long by so many people, that we in turn have passed it on to our own colleagues and so reinforced the apparent validity and common sense of the gospel.

    Scott-Morgan, Peter, The Unwritten Rules of the Game: Master Them, Shatter Them, and Break Through the Barriers to Organizational Change (1994), p. 137

    behaviorfear

  10. The manager whose conception of cause and effect in human behavior is mechanical must rely on the 'orneriness' of human nature for an explanation of the many forms of indifference or resistance to managerial influence. The only way he can conceive of to counteract them is to increase the threat of extrinsic punishment (which often aggravates the symptoms he is trying to eliminate)."[fn]"Increasing the threat of extrinsic punishment" reminded me of this widely circulated humorous quote of unknown origin: "The beatings will continue until morale improves.

    McGregor, Douglas, the professional manager (1967), p. 15

    behaviorpunishment

  11. If I have one piece of advice to young people, it's to break rules. Let's first assume you are delivering way more than what is expected of you. You have to do much more than the expected to compete today, because there are plenty of people out there happy to do the minimum. If you are already overdelivering, and breaking a rule will help you deliver more, then go ahead. Ask yourself a question: Will breaking a rule really help everyone out, not just myself? Is the answer yes? Then go ahead and break the rule. I'm not talking about doing anything criminal or unethical. I mean not following some stupid policy or convention. You'll have more fun and everyone will learn more. Most of all, you'll deliver more.

    Mackay, Harvey, We Got Fired!: . . . And It's the Best Thing That Ever Happened to Us (2004), p. 264

    rules

  12. You're stuck in a cube with a desktop computer and a phone with a cord so you can be there in person should your manager walk over to check up on whether or not you're working. The game becomes looking busy instead of working hard and solving problems and contributing. It's a game no one wins. You lose your freedom, your motivation, your soul, and in exchange for control over your life, your company gets little more than a show of work.

    Ressler, Cali; Thompson, Jody, Why Work Sucks and How to Fix It: No Schedules, No Meetings, No Joke–the Simple Change That Can Make Your Job Terrific (2008), p. 28

    control

  13. There are no answers in the employee handbook. The only solution is to change the game entirely.

    Ressler, Cali; Thompson, Jody, Why Work Sucks and How to Fix It: No Schedules, No Meetings, No Joke–the Simple Change That Can Make Your Job Terrific (2008), p. 3

    rules

  14. Techniques of control in the workplace became increasingly important as the body became the central problem of production. The early industrial employers needed to regulate, direct, constrain, anchor, and channel bodily energies for the purposes of sustained, often repetitive, productive activity. Still struggling to establish their legitimate authority, they invented techniques designed to control the laboring body. The French historian Michel Foucault has argued that these new techniques of industrial management laid the groundwork for a new kind of society, a 'disciplinary society', one in which bodily discipline, regulation, and surveillance are taken for granted.

    In the Age of the Smart Machine: The Future of Work and Power (1988), p. 319

    controldiscipline

  15. Techniques of control and the panoptic power they convey offer one such alternative. Information systems can alter many of the classic contingencies of the superior-subordinate relationship, providing certain information about the subordinates' behavior while eliminating the necessity of face-to-face engagement. They can transmit the presence of the omniscient observer and so induce compliance without the messy conflict-prone exertions of reciprocal relations.

    In the Age of the Smart Machine: The Future of Work and Power (1988), p. 323

    panopticism

  16. In the work of Frederick Taylor we have, I believe, the first clear statement that society is best served when human beings are placed at the disposal of their techniques and technology, that human beings are, in a sense, worth less than their machinery.

    Postman, Neil, Technopoly: The Surrender of Culture to Technology (1993), p. 52

    machineneo-Taylorism

  17. Another factor is too-close supervision. The capable, well-motivated man cannot find satisfaction on the job if he lacks sufficient scope to show what he can do.

    Rohrer, Hibler & Replogle; Flory, C.D., Managers for tomorrow (1967), p. 153

    overmanagement

  18. The mistake we make in thinking of character as something unified and all-encompassing is very similar to a kind of blind spot in the way we process information. Psychologists call this tendency the Fundamental Attribution Error (FAE), which is a fancy way of saying that when it comes to interpreting other people's behavior, human beings invariably make the mistake of overestimating the importance of fundamental character traits and underestimating the importance of the situation and context. We will always reach for a 'dispositional' explanation for events, as opposed to a contextual explanation.

    Gladwell, Malcolm, The Tipping Point: How Little Things Can Make a Big Difference (2002)

    accountabilitybehavior

  19. This codification, this rigor mortis that sets in around values and behaviors, is a problem unique to--and often devastating for--successful enterprises.

    Gerstner, Louis, Who Says Elephants Can't Dance?: Leading a Great Enterprise Through Dramatic Change (2004), p. 185

    rules

  20. As we all know, bureaucracies are supposed to operate 'by the rules.' They are places where individual initiative, enterprise, and creativity are supposed to take second place--if they are permitted at all!--to the policies and procedures that have been defined or authorized by those in charge of the organization as a whole. Weber observed that the bureaucratic approach to organization mechanized the process of administration, exactly as machines had routinized production in industry. And his writings make frequent reference to how this process of mechanization squeezes out the human dimension.

    Morgan, Gareth, Creative Organization Theory (1989), p. 49

    bureaucracymechanistic organization

← PreviousNext →21–40 of 60 quotes
Works quoted (51)