A quote from Abolishing performance appraisals: why they backfire and what to do instead
These various forms of appraisal are packaged as tools for 'accountability' rather than control. We are comfortable with accountability, but not control--only monsters seek control. Our comfort with accountability is not misplaced. It's a worthy goal, at least to the extent that it means people should take responsibility for their work. The problem lies not in desiring accountability, but in the means of ensuring accountability. Rather than promoting accountability as a value, we try to force people to be responsible. We impose measurement and formal judgment to make sure that people are held accountable. This is precisely what appraisal does. With good intentions, we adorn appraisal with upbeat and friendly terminology, but the features of control are undeniably present and felt by every employee who undergoes the process. Peter Block's observations accurately depict the reality of appraisal. Peter Block's Observations on Appraisal Performance appraisals are an instrument for social control. They are annual discussions, avoided more often than held, in which one adult identifies for another adult three improvement areas to work on over the next twelve months. You can soften them all you want, call them development discussions, have them on a regular basis, have the subordinate identify the improvement areas instead of the boss, and discuss values. None of this changes the basic transaction .... if the intent of appraisal is learning, it is not going to happen when the context of the dialogue is evaluation and judgment.
Coens, T.; Jenkins, M.; Block, P., Abolishing performance appraisals: why they backfire and what to do instead (2002), p. 82
Cite this
Pandoc: [@coens2002abolishing, p. 82]
BibTeX
@book{coens2002abolishing,
author = {Coens, T. and Jenkins, M. and Block, P.},
title = {Abolishing performance appraisals: why they backfire and what to do instead},
year = {2002},
publisher = {Berrett-Koehler Publishers},
isbn = {978-1-57675-200-5},
url = {http://books.google.com/books?id=TlpnMIYda9kC}
}CSL JSON
{
"id": "coens2002abolishing",
"type": "book",
"title": "Abolishing performance appraisals: why they backfire and what to do instead",
"author": [
{
"family": "Coens",
"given": "T."
},
{
"family": "Jenkins",
"given": "M."
},
{
"family": "Block",
"given": "P."
}
],
"issued": {
"date-parts": [
[
2002
]
]
},
"publisher": "Berrett-Koehler Publishers",
"ISBN": "978-1-57675-200-5",
"URL": "http://books.google.com/books?id=TlpnMIYda9kC"
}